I don’t live in Cleveland. I’m over the border in Cleveland Heights. I teach, but not in Cleveland (although I did spend four months earlier this year tutoring 6th graders at Rozelle Elementary in East Cleveland). This week I got an email from Linda Fox pointing me to a post on her website: Right As Usual.
I confess that I have not been following the details of the school levy vote in a few days because, by virtue of my residence, I won’t be voting in that particular election. But I read Linda’s post, and while I agree with her that such tactics are infuriating, I don’t see them as anything out of the ordinary for anyone professionally involved in politics. It sucks bilge water, but that’s the way it works.
Any good journalist — and that includes bloggers — keeps a circle of friends and experts to call upon when a topic is out of their league. In this case I called upon a Cleveland teacher whose opinion I high value: MaryBeth Matthews of Street Smarts.
I emailed the link to Linda’s post and asked MaryBeth her opinion. I caught her at a good time and she replied with clarity and passion. With her permission, here’s what she had to say:
Why would anyone be surprised?
This election strategy is not about the listening to the voice of the citizens. It’s about getting money to pay for the education of Cleveland’s children. Period.
The district is desperate.
The procedure for funding schools in the state of Ohio is so screwed up it was declared unconstitutional. There are committees and task forces in place to come up with a better way to pay for public education, but in the meantime the Big 8 districts are taking some big hits.
Cuts are devastating. Most affected are the kids in urban public schools, were the tax base has eroded due to abatements for big business, the flight of the middle class to the suburbs, and the fact big employers are either closing their doors, leaving the city, or are tax exempt non-profits.
This puts the burden of school taxes on the home owners, who rank the poorest in the nation. Children who have had the good fortune to be born to families a few miles away in suburbs that don’t need to abate taxes, are going to public schools that are safe and dry, have state-of-the-art technology, arts, sports, and small class sizes.
The voters in Cleveland turned down the school levy in November, but did they put any pressure on the state legislators to reform school funding?
No.
They simply pointed to Barbara Byrd Bennett’s salary, and wagged their fingers saying she was being paid too much. Perhaps they should be made aware of the salaries of the CEO’s of the more than 200 other non-profit organizations in the Cleveland area, and ask them what public benefit have they been doing to deserve their big fat pay checks.
Some of these folks make Barbara look like the poor relation. Start with Hundert at Case making 706K + perks and benefits.
(Feel like doing a little detective work. You can find the 990 and 990f tax forms here. )
We live in one big F—ed up system here in Cleveland.
Can our kids afford to wait until it gets fixed? If we don’t have an educated workforce, what companies will want to do business here? The kids are the first to be hurt by our misplaced priorities.
CMSD has done one crappy job of connecting and communicating with the citizens of Cleveland. People don’t understand the problems. The outrage of Clevelanders is misplaced.
Yes, there is waste in the district, as in any huge government organization. Comparatively speaking though, dollar for dollar the district has made huge strides in addressing some of these problems. The cuts have been huge. We need to look at these problems from a very different perspective if we are ever going to fix the schools.
The seeds of Cleveland’s future are our kids… but while we are busy building new playgrounds for the rich, the city’s core is starting to rot.
Because I’ve been spending so much time with the Wal Mart issue of late, I see a lot things through a Low Prices All The Time lens. Do we expect education to follow that path? Do we want to pay less and less for the education of other people’s children?
My figures are not current, but it wasn’t long ago that a Cleveland Height’s politician told me that 75 of the school-age students in the district were in private schools. It is my understanding that the figure is actually even higher in Beachwood.
Now more than 50 years since Brown vs. Board of Education we are living a whole new version of separate but equal. And the equal isn’t any more so today than in was in 1954.
Tim Russo has another take on the levy issue. Be sure to check him out as well.
My Soundtrack: El Manana by Gorillaz on WOXY.