From the Letters-To-The-Editor response to Salon’s Wal-Mart’s P.R. War by Liza Featherstone comes these thoughts (day pass required):
These families are also in severe economic denial — they could care less that Wal-Mart’s “price rollbacks” have rolled over jobs formerly held by American workers.
…trust me, if activism did result in marginally higher prices it would be perceived as blue-state intervention and micromanagement. It would be perceived as “those liberals” caring more about Malaysian children than American children. It would push more people to red-state politics.
…the problems with Wal-Mart are big-picture problems. But most Americans, especially the low- and low-middle-income Americans who shop at Wal-Mart, simply do not live in a big-picture universe.
…buys into the myth that Wal-Mart itself is the disease to cure, but it is merely a symptom. Target and most other corporate chains differ only in size and degree, not in kind. The labor unions spending millions of dollars to try “changing Wal-Mart” have a poor understanding of the systemic issues.
The downfall of Wal-Mart may not be due to public pressure, but due to its strategy of only caring about the bottom line. There aren’t any more price concessions to squeeze out of suppliers.
Wal-Mart, as you said, makes a community poorer as part of its corporate planning, thus forcing more of us to have little choice but to buy from them. Evil genius if I ever heard of it.
All it cost Wal-Mart for this national recognition was $50,000!
I would like to see someone do a comparative study on the different big-box stores (Wal-Mart, Costco, Target, et al.) and rank them in terms of worker pay and treatment, benefits, health coverage, etc. For those who need the price break of a big box, it would be nice to know if we have choices between them as to which is more socially destructive, and which is more socially benign.
I’ve been subscribing to Salon for more than seven years. I don’t recall this volume of reader responses in the past.
Wal Mart is not the problem, but it has become the poster child.
My Soundtrack: Fix You by Cold Play on WOXY.