
The response to offense speech must not be censorship. The response to offense speech must be more speech. Yesterday blogger Jane Hamsher posted a photoshopped picture of Senator Joseph Lieberman in black face. Lieberman was righteously indignant and demanded that his primary opponent denounce the image.
Hamsher yanked the image at the request of Lieberman’s opponent: Ned Lamont.
The important thing here is not that Hamsher deleted the image, but why she deleted it. She was OK with offending Lieberman and his supporters. She knew that they would be offended when she first saw the image. And anyone who thinks she had an epiphany and realized it was a bad thing to offend those people believes that we found the weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.
Hamsher deleted the offending image because its negatives far out-weighed any positives for her candidate.
She made a political decision based upon her agenda and her goals, and I think that’s fine. That’s not-self censorship. That’s enlightened self-interest.
Then there is the matter of Mark Fiore’s Smarty Bombsalot.
I’m offended by what Fiore says in this latest animation, but I’m not about to demand he take it down. The American Nazis did have a right to march in Skokie, Illinois. And counter demonstrators have a right to march right along side them.
I had a brief exchange a few months ago over another animation he did about Jack Abramoff and his Borsalino. I wrote Fiore that time because I thought he was unaware of the significance of the image he chose to use. My purpose that time was to educate, not demand censorship.
So what did Fiore say that I don’t like? In the first panel of the animation the caption asks:
What do you do when a militant Islamic Group lobs rockets into your country and grabs a few of your soldiers?
Let’s stop right there. If you are the United States or any other sovereign nation, the answer is:
You ramp up your military forces and kicked the living shit out of them.
But if you’re the sovereign nation of Israel, in Fiore’s world, you’re not suppossed to do that.
How whack is that?
Bill Mahr said it very well yesterday:
As I watch so much of the world ask Israel for restraint in a way no other country would (Can you imagine what Bush would do if a terrorist organization took over Canada and was lobbing missiles into Montana, Maine and Illinois?) — and, by the way, does anyone ever ask Hezbollah for restraint. you know, like, please stop firing your rockets aimed PURPOSEFULLY at civilians? — it strikes me that the world IS Mel Gibson.
Most of the time, the anti-semitism is under control, but that demon lives inside and when the moon is full, or there’s been enough alcohol consumed, or Israel is forced to kill people in its own defense, then it comes out.
And I’ll say it again. Robert Goldberg still has nothing to apologize for.
My Soundtrack: Alternate Ending by Staggering Statistics on WOXY.