New Rule: just as it is not OK to just paraphrase a famous quote and then make up a plausible attribution, it is not OK to use words that you think you know the meaning of and just blabber on. That’s why a guy named Samuel Johnson spent so much creating a thing called a dictionary. The word that set me off this morning? Moot.
From Merriam-Webster’s 10th Collegiate Dictionary:
1: a deliberative assembly primarily for the administration of justice; especially : one held by the freemen of an Anglo-Saxon community 2 obsolete : ARGUMENT, DISCUSSION;
2: archaic : to discuss from a legal standpoint : ARGUE 2 a : to bring up for discussion : BROACH b : DEBATE;
3a: open to question : DEBATABLE b : subjected to discussion : DISPUTED;
4: deprived of practical significance : made abstract or purely academic.
From Dictionary
moot 1 /mut/ Pronunciation Key – Show Spelled Pronunciation[moot] Pronunciation Key – Show IPA Pronunciation
-adjective
1. open to discussion or debate; debatable; doubtful: a moot point.
2. of little or no practical value or meaning; purely academic.
3. Chiefly Law. not actual; theoretical; hypothetical.
-verb (used with object)
4. to present or introduce (any point, subject, project, etc.) for discussion.
5. to reduce or remove the practical significance of; make purely theoretical or academic.
6. Archaic. to argue (a case), esp. in a mock court.
-noun
7. an assembly of the people in early England exercising political, administrative, and judicial powers.
8. an argument or discussion, esp. of a hypothetical legal case.
9. Obsolete. a debate, argument, or discussion.
[Origin: bef. 900; ME mot(e) meeting, assembly, OE gemÅt; c. ON mÅt, D gemoet meeting. See meet1]
From the Cambridge Advanced Learner’s Dictionary
moot (DISCUSSION) verb [T] FORMAL to suggest something for discussion: The idea was first mooted as long ago as the 1840s. His name was mooted as a possible successor.
moot adjective tending to be discussed or argued about and having no definite answer: It’s a moot point whether building more roads reduces traffic congestion.
noun [C] SPECIALIZED a trial or discussion dealing with an imaginary legal case, performed by students as part of their legal training but in exactly the same way as a real one: a moot court
moot adjective MAINLY US LEGAL having no practical use or meaning: The district attorney said if McVeigh is given the death penalty and his conviction is upheld on appeal, the state prosecution would become moot.
The misused definition that drives me bonkers is No. 4 in the first case, No.’s 2, 5 and 8 in the second case and the final meaning in the third case.
In the past week I have heard several ostensibly intelligent people on various public radio shows use the word as a way of dismissing another’s argument; as in: there’s no point in even discussing that, it’s moot.
If the other party feels there’s something of substance to yet discuss then the point is not moot in the obsolete sense, but is rather moot in the broader sense of being a debatable point.
Using moot has become yet another way of shutting down discussion; another way of saying: you’re an idiot, go away.
Word do not mean what we want them to mean. We do not live in Orwell’s hell.