I’ve long been a fan of Jeremy Rifkin. I first discovered him in 1987 when I read his 10th book: Time Wars. I got to meet Rifkin at a Toronto environmental conference in 1995 when he was promoting his book: The End Of Work.
This week I’m reading his most recent book: The the Third Industrial Revolution: How Lateral Power Is Transforming Energy, the Economy, and the World. About a third of the way through the book I came across a passage that made me think of our local effort at communication: The Civic Commons.
Rifkin writes:
[T]he province of Utrecht[, the Netherlands]…has begun a conversation with its citizenry, the local business community, university researchers, and even high schools – essentially inviting the entire region into the game. The master plan has gone lateral. It is now a platform for a province-wide discussion on how to achieve a transition into a Third Industrial Revolution economy.
People are critiquing parts of the master plan platform, offering their own ideas, and even voting on their favorite projects. In the process, the new players are connecting up to share their expertise, pooling their mutual interests, and creating networks within and across the five-pillar [1. shifting to renewable energy; 2. transforming the building stock of every continent into micro-power plants to collect renewable energies on site; 3. deploying hydrogen and other storage technologies in every building and throughout the infrastructure to store intermittent energies; 4. using Internet technology to transform the power grid of every continent into an energy-sharing intergrid that acts just like the Internet (when millions of buildings are generating a small amount of energy locally, on site, they can sell surplus back to the gird and share electricity with their continental neighbors); and 5. transitioning the transport fleet to electric plug-in and fuel cell vehicles that can buy and sell electricity on a smart, continental interactive power grid] skeleton vision. The TIR has become a community exercise, the Dutch version of the old American barn raising, where the whole community comes together to build the structure. This is democratization of energy, and what distributed capitalism is really all about.
And it’s working. The population of the province is becoming intimately engaged in its own economic future. “Not in my backyard” is being replaced by a collaborative effort to steward the neighborhood biosphere.
If there is a single lesson to take away from the experience we’ve garnered in engaging master plans, it is that the process itself is a community exercise. That is, it requires participation of all three sectors – government, the business community, and neighborhood civil society organization. p. 103
This week marks the first anniversary of The Civic Commons and I’ve taken some time to look back at the online conversations. I’m not impressed. What has impressed me has been the conversations at two Civic Commons gatherings I’ve attended where people sat face to face and listened to each other. Listening is optional in cyberspace.
At both of the Civic Commons events I took part in at their offices — It’s the Sprawl, Stupid: The Budget Buster No One’s Talking About and the National Day of Conversation 2011 — I was wowed by the diversity and expertise of those who came to engage in the conversation. The only aspect that I found lacking, and I’m as much to blame for this as anyone, was that when the conversation ended, it was over; there hasn’t been, at least for me, a continuing conversation on what I thought where important discussions.
Cleveland, or perhaps more appropriately, North East Ohio, is not Utrecht, but I have to wonder what the factors are that generated this conversation in a province of The Netherlands that we’re not getting here.
Why are the Dutch embracing the 21st century and the Third Industrial Revolution while Cleveland is mired in the 20th century and the death throes of the Second Industrial Revolution?