The most fervent booster of all things Cleveland that I ever knew personally was George Nemeth. George was a high energy thinker and disciple of Ed Morrison (brother of Hunter Morrison).
During those heady Brewed Fresh Daily (the initials were not a coincidence) day George held us all together and generally he and I agreed on most topics. Cleveland’s future, however, was not one of them. That changed sometime in 2011.
George Nemeth, booster turned basher.
Now that multimedia maestro George Nemeth, who for years has been part of the conversation about how to improve Cleveland, has moved at least part-time to California, he’s hurling bombs toward the North Coast.
His new blog : CLE+ SUCKS.
“I’ve had it,” reads the initial post. “With all the lame, indefensible cliches of why all of you LOVE CLE+. Let me tell you brothers and sisters — this city is the pits.”
He says he plans to post videos and links about why Cleveland is no plum.
“Maybe then you’ll understand that it’s time to change. Or get outta dodge.”
Tipoff asked Nemeth, proprietor of the web page “Brewed Fresh Daily,” if he hadn’t gotten his coffee yet.
He said he’s serious about slamming Cleveland and hopes it shatters some rose-colored glasses.
“The real goal is to get the Cleveland cheerleaders to pay attention to people like Tyler (a line cook at Parallax who moved here from CA) who can’t get out of here fast enough,” he said.
He also said “cupcakes” in Cleveland, the pollyannaish civic cheerleaders, float high-minded ideas that “don’t amount to a hill of beans in a town where inept leaders have presided for decades over a bankrupt, demoralized, de-motivated (and shrinking I might add) populace that care more about sports than their neighbors.”
Yeah, George would be all over Blockchain. If it were not for the Bitcoin bubble—and yes, Bitcoin is a bubble that will, in the way of all bubbles, burst—we would not be talking about Blockchain as the next big thing public-money grab. Thankfully, Sam Allard is still here and writing.
Sam, reporting in What the Hell is Blockchain, Anyway? Notes from #Blockland for Scene, lays out the story, but six paragraphs in the middle of Sam’s piece grabbed my attention:
Take a look at this conversation in Crain’s from March, before the first local Blockland meeting and before Jon Pinney’s June City Club speech that kicked a lot of these conversations into a sustained high gear. It’s a sponsored article—that is, a paid advertisement—from Benesch, the region’s third-largest law firm, which incidentally employs only five minority partners of its total 82.
Benesch attorneys Sean T. Peppard and Michael D. Stovsky were speaking about blockchain to promote their firm’s engagement with related issues.
Their take was that blockchain’s applications in the business world had a lot to do with contracts.
“Imagine a manufacturing company that wants to use 3D printing vendors all over the world to manufacture thousands of highly engineered parts for it,” said Stovsky. “Rather than the inefficiency of having face-to-face negotiations with hundreds or thousands of vendors, the parties can agree in an electronic environment on the specific contract terms.”
That electronic environment sounds a lot like a much more efficient, and more popular, existing technological application, namely email, but anyway. Here’s Peppard, elaborating on what he sees as the impacts on Northeast Ohio:
“Imagine a situation in which a large manufacturer can reduce its own capital expenditures by farming out manufacturing to 3D and 4D [Do 4D printers—as a commenter to Sam’s story observed—print time? JH] printers all over the world,” he said. “These are companies that can manufacture precision parts to spec better, faster and cheaper—all while maintaining the integrity of the contracting process and the intellectual property rights of the company in the specifications and other materials provided to the vendors.”
This is a hypothetical paragraph, but it sounds like some Cleveland employees may be out of work in the scenario it envisions. And if one of blockchain’s applications will be to make outsourcing local labor even easier and cheaper than it already is, that’s a step in the wrong direction for the region’s economy. (This is only one case, of course, but it’s the one that leading local lawyers saw fit to mention in an advertisement on the topic.)
Roldo Bartimole, still very much the cogent observer of all-things-Cleveland, left this comment on Sam’s piece:
Thanks for all the words Sam to flesh out the new corporate grab bag.
They call it Blockchain but it’s surely Bullshit. Another hand in the pockets of ordinary people who should just shut up because they can’t possibly understand the beauty of their betters newest gimmick.
Read every word but don’t understand the part that doesn’t go with SUBSIDIES from the taxpayers.
Please keep up the questioning because we don’t have another news outlet.
I attempted to call bullshit on Blockchain myself during a Sound of Ideas broadcast back in July, but there’s only so much you can do when you call into a radio program.
There is nothing innovative about yet another Innovation Center in Cleveland.
This is just yet another example of the cupcakes—the men behind the curtain—grabbing all the public money they can.