Today was a Yom Iyun, a day of study, for Cleveland’s Jewish educators. The two breakout sessions I took part in — Special Needs In The Supplementary School with Laurie Gross Krammer and State Of The Arts with Robbie Gringras — were both very good.
At the end of my classes I always asks students a question I learned from Master Teacher Sue Arnold:
What is the most important piece you learned today?
In that spirit, I want to share with you the most important piece of learning that I walked away with today: a different way, for me, to think about Israel.
It comes from keynote speaker Yonatan Ariel, executive director of Makom, the Israel engagement network. During his remarks he described three layers of being for Israel:
Israel is the Jewish Sanctuary.
Israel is the Jewish Repository.
Israel is the Jewish Laboratory.
By the first, Israel is the Jewish sanctuary, Ariel means that Israel is both a sacred space for the Jewish people and, perhaps more importantly for those who remember when there was no safe space, Israel is the lifeboat to which we can all retreat when the rest of the world is hostile or uncaring.
By the second, Israel is the Jewish repository, Ariel means that Israel is the place where all of Jewish history is stored and preserved; where every aspect of what it means to be a Jew is protected.
By the third, and this was the most important piece that I learned today, Ariel meant that Israel is where Judaism evolves and grows; where Torah scholars still argue and search for meaning in ancient texts so that they might make life better today. Israel is where all Jews are in conversation about what it means to be a Jew and how that will change Judaism and Israel tomorrow.
Ariel said one more important lesson: that we are all both hugging and wrestling with Israel. Too many in the United States, and in the rest of the diaspora, believe that we are only allowed to hug, give our unconditional support to, Israel. I’ve always thought that wrong, but I’ve never heard it articulated so well as I did this morning.
We have always been the people that wrestled. Our vary name, the children of Israel, comes from the night spent Jacob spent wrestling with God. God wrestling is what we do; it is what we are.