The Cleveland Plain Dealer (it dropped the word Cleveland during the city’s tough times in the 1960s) is not unknown for shabby treatment of its employees. Read: reporters.
Nor has it often managed to escape revelations of its crimes and misdemeanors. After all, it employs reporters. They tend to want to report. And talk.
I have come to believe that the majority of people (includeing our President) do not understand the function of reporting. Therefore, of the reporter’s state of mind. At least the good ones.
Everyone who knows what has been going in Cleveland with its daily newspaper knows what I’m going to write about.
After chopping 22 reporters—all union—and four nonunion, from its payroll the newspaper boss couldn’t wait a week before he struck another blow. This one to the few remaining Plain Dealer people. The management had already separated the staff by isolating the Cleveland.com staff from the PD staff.
This second quick blow could be attributed to Chris Quinn. Quinn is listed daily as Editor, Advance Ohio/Cleveland.com. But he’s the top guy. If he didn’t make the decision, he allowed it.
In this time of pandemic, these decisions are not just shabby but purposely cruel.
This, I believe, has to do with the future of a newspaper here.
It sort of leaves the newspaper itself one step from a permanent garbage pail. Not published four days a week. Not published one day a week. Not published as a paper at all.
That appears to be the strategy.
Produce a product that won’t be missed.
Indignities have befallen PD reporters before. Likely heading that list was a 1982 decision that should be near the top of any list of journalistic malpractice
The newspaper RETRACTED an investigative effort by Walt Bogdanich, now an investigative reporter for the New York Times. Elite city lawyers here had given thumbs up for the reporting. So the PD published.
Bogdanich’s expose reported that Teamster boss Jackie Presser was a government informer.
That’s pretty startling news. And it got backlash. From Teamsters.
It didn’t take long for the other, more pliable lawyers to come in play for the PD and Newhouse retreat.
The Plain Dealer, after publishing the expose, went from one of the city’s establishment firms, Baker-Hostetler, to get a more Teamster-friendly and politically connected law firms, headed by John Climaco. It’s called fixing the result.
That Sunday afternoon, after the retraction appeared, the deep distrust of the PD management was revealed by editorial employees picketing the newspaper.
I wrote at that time: “PD reporters acted sharply because of their trust of reporter Walt Bogdanich… and general mistrust of the editors.”
Some things hardly ever change.
Bogdanich said he had tape recordings of government officials revealing that Presser was an informant. The editors declined to listen to the tapes.
Now, in a move that can only be read as a tactic to make Plain Dealer side reporters writhe in disgust, managers have decided the remaining reporters can no longer report on Cleveland or Cuyahoga County matters. Their normal digs.
They have been demoted to the outer counties—Geauga, Lake, Lorain, Medina and Portage.
They MUST not report on Cleveland and county matters.
A slap in the face. A kick in the ass.
It is reminiscent of when PD reporters were assigned to review the Glenville riots. They did the job. Then they were told their work wouldn’t be published. Reason: They were unqualified to reach the conclusion they had. Soon after the New York Times sent a team for a similar postmortum. The Times reporters came to the same conclusions as the PD reporters had. The Times plastered the story over its front page.
The same can be said of reporters the PD now is dissing—Rachel Dissell, John Caniglia, John Petkovic, Michelle Jarboe, Laura DeMarco and Patrick O’Donnell.
They have done stellar work. So what?
This is a business. Get it.
How can any editor dismiss that kind of talent and send them essentially to the bench instead of working them in the main lineup of news coverage?
Only a power-hungry editor willing to do the work of the Newhouses no matter the cost to the newspaper or the community would follow those orders.
Chris Quinn apparently has qualified. More and more you hear from PD and former PD people of his power moves.
I could go on with similar malfeasance at the PD. Frankly, I’m tired of it and happy that the Cleveland Scene and Sam Allard have expended the effort to highlight these matters. The latest from Allard is worth reading and saving:
Just to prove this PD hasn’t lost its touch here is a Look Back over 25 years of media malfeasances.
Click on the image below to download the entire issue of Point Of Viəw.
Click on the image above to download the entire issue of Point Of Viəw.